By Peter Castagno on Nov 21,
2019 10:15 am
“The Patriot Act extension
passed the House with nearly all Democrats voting for it. When Pres. Trump
signs it into law, Democrats will be just as responsible for warrantless
surveillance as Trump and the GOP. Neither party is looking out for you.” – Rep.
Justin Amash
House Democrats voted almost
unanimously to extend the Patriot Act in their budget bill on Tuesday, granting
massive surveillance powers to a president they are trying to impeach because
of the danger his corruption poses to national security. The apparently
contradictory action reflects a long tradition of bipartisan consensus in
giving intelligence agencies free rein to violate the constitution and abuse
their covert powers.
“Very cool way to resist Trump
by ensuring he continues to have terrifying authoritarian surveillance
powers,” tweeted Evan Greer, deputy director for digital rights
advocacy group Fight For The Future.
What is the Patriot Act?
The Patriot Act of 2001 was
the essential legislation that enabled the NSA and other government
agencies to conduct mass surveillance and warrantless searches against
Americans with no oversight. First introduced by Joe Biden in 1995 as The Omnibus Counterterrorism Act of 1995, the bill was
enacted after 9/11 under the pretense of fighting terrorism.
Because of its extreme
mandate, the Patriot Act included sunset clauses to fade out
its provisions unless Congress voted for their reauthorization. Congress has
repeatedly done so, including the latest three month extension, which was
quietly included in a government funding resolution by House Speaker Pelosi,
who once called the bill “a massive invasion of privacy,” and other Democratic
leaders.
“The Patriot Act extension
passed the House with nearly all Democrats voting for it,” tweeted Rep. Justin Amash. “When Pres. Trump signs it into law,
Democrats will be just as responsible for warrantless surveillance as Trump and
the GOP. Neither party is looking out for you. That’s why I’m an independent.”
Amash, a former Republican who
left the party in protest of Trump’s leadership, proposed an amendment to
remove the Patriot Act extension from the budget bill, but it was blocked by
Democrats on the Rules Committee. Only 10 Democrats voted against the
resolution, including “the Squad” of Rashida Tlaib, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez,
Ayanna Pressley, and Ilhan Omar. The bill passed 231-192, mostly on party lines.
“The continuing resolution
would reauthorize a mass surveillance authority that has never been proven
useful and that has consistently broken the laws and rules governing
surveillance,” tweeted Demand Progress.
U.S. Government’s History Of
Abusing Surveillance Powers
Beyond the violation of civil
liberties posed by mass government surveillance of citizens, critics argue the
U.S. government’s history of abusing its covert powers for sinister purposes
proves it is too irresponsible to merit such vast power.
The Snowden leaks revealed how the National Security Agency (NSA) violates the fourth amendment to spy on American citizens,
but beyond the NSA, agencies like the FBI, CIA, DHS, and DEA have all abused mass surveillance powers. The
scope of their activities is not publicly known.
The FBI, for example, has a
long list of crimes including the Palmer Raids and torturing Puerto Rican independence activists, and has long
devoted public resources to illegally surveilling nonviolent civil society groups and protest movements.
Patriot Act Dangerously
Expands CIA Powers
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) warns that
perhaps the most dangerous aspect of the Patriot Act is expanding the CIA’s
power to spy on Americans. The ACLU cites Operation CHAOS, when the CIA spied
on student activists and people opposed to Vietnam in the 1960s and 1970s, as
an example of the agency’s willingness to infringe on lawful political activity
protected under the first and fourth amendments.
The CIA’s involvement in coups, executions, mind control experiments, and other nefarious pursuits have
led critics, including multiple presidents, to view it as more of an
unaccountable criminal organization than a legitimate democratic institution.
After being asked about the
creation of the CIA, President Truman told his biographer: “I think it was a mistake. If
I’d known what was going to happen, I never would have done it.”
“Those fellows in the CIA
don’t just report on wars and the like, they go out and make their own, and
there’s nobody to keep track of what they’re up to,” said Truman. “They spend billions of dollars on stirring up
trouble so they’ll have something to report on. They’ve become … it’s become a
government all of its own and all secret. They don’t have to account to
anybody.”
“That’s a very dangerous thing
in a democratic society, and it’s got to be put a stop to,” said Truman. One
month after the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, who once said he
wanted to “splinter the CIA into a thousand pieces and scatter it into the
winds,” Truman publicized his warnings with a Washington Post op-ed titled
“Limit CIA Role to Intelligence.”
Eisenhower also famously
warned the American public of “the military industrial complex,” the unaccountable nexus
of intelligence organizations and their corporate, political, and military
allies which he believed would subvert US democracy without the vigilance of an
“alert and knowledgeable citizenry.”
Journalist David Talbot, who
detailed the life of CIA director Allen Dulles in his book “The Devil’s Chessboard,” views Snowden’s revelations as a manifestation of Eisenhower
and Truman’s warnings: “The surveillance state that Snowden and others
have exposed is very much a legacy of the Dulles past. I think Dulles would
have been delighted by how technology and other developments have allowed the
American security state to go much further than he went.”
Snowden shares Talbot’s fears
that new technology will give the surveillance state unprecedented power. “The
greatest danger still lies ahead, with the refinement of artificial
intelligence capabilities, such as facial and pattern recognition,” the whistleblower told the Guardian in September.