OCT 14, 2019
Chris Hedges, an ordained
Presbyterian minister, gave this sermon Sunday at the Claremont Presbyterian
Church in Claremont, Calif.
Immanuel Kant coined the term
“radical evil.” It was the privileging of one’s own interest over that of
others, effectively reducing those around you to objects to be manipulated and
used for your own ends. But Hannah Arendt, who also
used the term “radical evil,” saw that it was worse than merely treating others
as objects. Radical evil, she wrote, rendered vast numbers of people
superfluous. They possessed no value at all. They were, once they could not be
utilized by the powerful, discarded as human refuse.
We live in an age of radical
evil. The architects of this evil are despoiling the earth and driving the
human species toward extinction. They are stripping us of our most basic civil
liberties and freedoms. They are orchestrating the growing social inequity,
concentrating wealth and power in the hands of a cabal of global oligarchs.
They are destroying our democratic institutions, turning elected office into a
system of legalized bribery, stacking our courts with judges who invert
constitutional rights so that unlimited corporate money invested in political
campaigns is disguised as the right to petition the government or a form of
free speech. Their seizure of power has vomited up demagogues and con artists
including Donald Trump and Boris Johnson,
each the distortion of a failed democracy. They are turning America’s poor
communities into internal militarized colonies where police carry out lethal
campaigns of terror and use the blunt instrument of mass incarceration as a
tool of social control. They are waging endless wars in the Middle East and
diverting half of all discretionary spending to a bloated military. They are
placing the rights of the corporation above the rights of the citizen.
Arendt captured the radical
evil of a corporate capitalism in which people are rendered superfluous—surplus labor as
Karl Marx said—and pushed to the margins of society where they and their
children are no longer considered to have value, value always determined by the
amount of money produced and amassed. But as the Gospel of Luke reminds us,
“what is prized by human beings is an abomination in the sight of God.”
Who are those who would
sacrifice us on the altar of global capitalism? How did they amass the power to
deny us a voice, to insist that the earth is an inert commodity they have a
right to exploit until the ecosystem that sustains life collapses and the human
species, along with most other species, becomes extinct?
These architects of radical
evil have been here from the beginning. They are the slaveholders who crammed
men, women and children into the holds of ships and sold them in auctions in
Charleston and Montgomery, rending families apart, taking from them their
names, language, religion and culture. They wielded the whips, the chains, the
dogs and the slave
patrols. They orchestrated the holocaust of slavery, and when slavery was
abolished, after a war that left 700,000 dead, they used convict leasing—slavery
by another name—along with lynching and black codes,
to carry out a reign of terror that continues today in our deindustrialized
cities and our prisons. Black and brown bodies are worth nothing to our
corporate masters when on the streets of our decayed cities, but locked in
cages they each generate 50 or 60 thousand dollars a year. Some people say the
system does not work. They are wrong. The system works exactly as it is
designed to work.
These architects of radical
evil are the white militias and Army units that stole the land, decimated the
herds of buffalo, signed the treaties that were promptly violated and carried
out a campaign of genocide against indigenous people, penning the few who
remained in prisoner of war camps. They are the gun thugs, Baldwin-Felts
and Pinkerton agents who gunned down, by the hundreds, American
workers struggling to organize, forces of the kind that today oversee the
bonded labor of workers in China, Vietnam and Bangladesh. They are the
oligarchs, J.P. Morgan, Rockefeller and Carnegie, who paid for these rivers of
blood, and who today, like Tim Cook at Apple and
Jeff Bezos at Amazon,
amass staggering fortunes from human misery.
We know these architects of radical
evil. They are the DNA of American capitalism. You can find them on the
commodity desks at Goldman Sachs. The financial firm’s commodities index is the
most heavily traded in the world. These traders buy up futures of rice, wheat,
corn, sugar and livestock and jack up the commodity prices by as much as 200%
on the global market so that the poor in Asia, Africa and Latin America can no
longer afford basic staples, and starve. Hundreds of millions of people go
hungry to feed this mania for profit, this radical evil that sees human beings,
including children, as worth nothing.
These architects of radical
evil extract the coal, oil and gas, poisoning our air, soil and water, while
demanding huge taxpayer subsidies and blocking the urgent transition to renewable
energy. They are the massive corporations that own the factory farms, egg
hatcheries and dairy farms where tens of billions of animals endure horrendous
abuse before being needlessly slaughtered, part of an animal agriculture
industry that is one of the leading multifactorial causes of climate
catastrophe. They are the generals and arms manufacturers. They are the
bankers, hedge fund managers and global speculators who looted $7 trillion from
the U.S. treasury after the pyramid schemes and fraud they carried out imploded
the global economy in 2007-2008. They are the goons in state security who make
us the most spied-upon, watched, monitored and photographed population in human
history. When your government watches you 24 hours a day you cannot use the word
“liberty.” This is the relationship between a master and a slave.
Corporate culture serves a
faceless system. It is, as Hannah Arendt wrote, “the rule of nobody and for
this very reason perhaps the least human and most cruel form of rulership.” It
will stop at nothing. Anyone or any movement that attempts to impede their
profits will be targeted for obliteration. These architects of radical evil are
incapable of reform. Appealing to their better nature is a waste of time. They
don’t have one. They have rigged the system, elections dominated by corporate
money, the courts, the press a vast burlesque show for profit, which is why
they spend so much time focused on Trump. There is no way to vote against the
interests of Goldman Sachs or Exxon, Shell, BP and Chevron, which along with
the other top 20 fossil fuel corporations have contributed 35% of all
energy-related carbon dioxide and methane emissions worldwide—480
billion tons of carbon dioxide equivalent since 1965.
We know these architects of
radical evil. They have been and always will be with us.
But who are those who resist?
Where do they come from? What historical, social and cultural forces created
them?
They too are familiar. They
are Denmark
Vesey, Nat
Turner, John Brown, Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglass. They are Sitting
Bull, Crazy Horse and Chief
Joseph. They are Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony and Emma Goldman.
They are “Big
Bill” Haywood, Joe Hill and
Eugene V. Debs. They are Woody Guthrie, Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm
X, Ella Baker and
Fannie Lou Hamer. They are Andrea Dworkin and
Caesar Chavez. They are those who from the beginning fought back, often to be
defeated by this radical evil but knowing they were called to defy it, even at
the cost of their own reputations, financial security, social standing and
sometimes their lives.
The architects of radical evil
are disemboweling every last social service program funded by the taxpayers,
from education to Social Security, because lives that do not swell their
profits are considered superfluous. Let the sick die. Let many of the poor—41 million people,
including children—go to bed hungry. Let families be tossed into the streets.
Let the young graduate have no meaningful employment. Let the U.S. prison
system, with 25% of the world’s prison population, swell. Let torture continue.
Let assault rifles proliferate to fuel the epidemic of mass shootings. Let the
roads, bridges, dams, levees, power grids, rail lines, subways, bus services,
schools and libraries crumble or close. Let the rising temperatures, the freak
weather patterns, the monster cyclones and hurricanes, the droughts, the
flooding, the tornadoes, the wildfires, the melting polar ice caps, the
poisoned water systems and the polluted air worsen until the species dies.
Many in the church are
complicit in this radical evil, failing to name it and denounce it, just as we
failed to see in the thousands of men, women and children who were lynched the
very crucifixion itself, as James
Cone pointed out. And this complicity and silence condemns us. It is
why W.E.B. Du Bois called “white religion” a “miserable failure.”
“Black people did not need to
go to seminary and study theology to know that white Christianity was
fraudulent,” Cone wrote in “The Cross and the Lynching Tree.” “As a teenager in
the South where whites treated blacks with contempt, I and other blacks knew
that the Christian identity of whites was not a true expression of what it
means to follow Jesus. Nothing their theologians and preachers could say would
convince us otherwise. We wondered how whites could live with their
hypocrisy—such blatant contradiction of the man from Nazareth. (I am still
wondering about that!) White conservative Christianity’s blatant endorsement of
lynching as a part of its religion, and white liberal Christians’ silence about
lynching placed both outside of Christian identity. I could not find one sermon
or theological essay, not to mention a book, opposing lynching by a prominent
liberal white preacher. There was no way a community could support or ignore
lynching in America, while still representing in word and deed the one who was
lynched by Rome.”
We have failed to denounce the
Christian fascists who peddle a magic Jesus who will make us rich, a Jesus who
blesses America above other countries and the white race above other races, a
Jesus who turns the barbarity of war into a holy crusade, for the heretics they
are. And we have failed, as well, to confront the radical evil of corporate
capitalism. Let us not once again render our faith a miserable failure.
Defying evil cannot be
rationally defended. It makes a leap into the moral, which is beyond rational
thought. It refuses to place a monetary value on human life or the natural
world. It refuses to see anyone as superfluous. It acknowledges human life,
indeed all life, as sacred. And this is why, as Arendt points out, the only
morally reliable people are not those who say “this is wrong” or “this should
not be done,” but those who say “I can’t do this.”
Those who come out of a
religious tradition, any religious tradition, have a responsibility to fight
this latest iteration of radical evil, which is swiftly ensuring that our
species and many other species will not have a future on this earth. It is our religious
duty to place our bodies in front of the machine, as many of us did in
the protests
organized by Extinction Rebellion last week around the globe.
“The law, as presently revered
and taught and enforced, is becoming an enticement to lawlessness,” Dan Berrigan wrote.
“Lawyers and laws and courts and penal systems are nearly immobile before a
shaken society, which is making civil disobedience a civil (I dare say a
religious) duty. The law is aligning itself more and more with forms of power
whose existence is placed more and more in question. … So, if they would obey
the law, [people] are being forced, in the present crucial instance, either to
disobey God or to disobey the law of humanity.”
Let us not in this present
historical period replicate our sins of the past. Let us affirm our faith by
affirming our defiance, our willingness to engage in the acts of sustained
civil disobedience against the forces of radical evil. Let future generations
say of us that we tried, that we were not complicit through our collaboration
or our silence. There will be a cost. History shows us that. All moral battles
have a cost, and if there is not a cost then the battle is not moral. Accept
becoming an outcast. Jesus, after all, was an outcast. We are called by God to
defy radical evil. This defiance is the highest form of spirituality.
